Goodfella`s Pizza in Wabash

Goodfella`s Pizza in Wabash
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

1118 Stitt St, Wabash, IN 46992-2200, Wabash

Overview

Cuisine
  • Pizza
  • Italian
Features
  • Seating

Restaurant Hours

Monday

11:00 am

Wednesday

11:00 am

Friday

11:00 am

Sunday

11:00 am

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Goodfella`s Pizza
JE
Judy Easterday
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Good pizza, subs and pasta!

Goodfella`s Pizza
KH
Kathleen Heuer
google
11.18.2018
5/5

Delicious Deep Pockets!

Goodfella`s Pizza
SH
Stoney Hobson
google
11.01.2018
5/5

Excellent pizza business

Goodfella`s Pizza
JE
Jodi Egner
google
10.26.2018
5/5

Excellent food! The thin crust is exceptional- and toppings are as plentiful as tasty!

Goodfella`s Pizza
BM
Brittany Mudd
google
10.18.2018
3/5

The food is good but to greasy

Goodfella`s Pizza
RT
Rhonda Tyner
google
10.04.2018
5/5

Great pizza especially the Enforcer

Goodfella`s Pizza
DM
David Moyer
google
09.24.2018
5/5

Great pizza and al of the rest of there food are very good don't forget about there 18" pizza special on Friday and Saturday

Goodfella`s Pizza
JW
Justin Wilcox
google
08.27.2018
4/5

Great wraps and subs.

Goodfella`s Pizza
SS
Sabrina Schindler
google
08.20.2018
5/5

Fantastic pizza pla and the best customer service

Goodfella`s Pizza
NH
Nicholas Hoover-Hill
google
08.05.2018
5/5

The pizza was really good.

Goodfella`s Pizza
JE
Jerrid Edmonson Sr.
google
07.13.2018
5/5

Nice/clean place to eat. Pizza is awesome.

Goodfella`s Pizza
SP
Steph Peebles
google
06.05.2018
5/5

Shana was great! This is a friendly place for those with gluten and dairy allergies :) I brought my own dairy free cheese and she added it to my pizza!

Goodfella`s Pizza
EF
Edith Frey
google
04.03.2018
3/5

Had to wait way too long for my order and especially after being told that my sandwiches were JUST COMING OUTTA THE OVEN AND BEING CUT I had at least another 15min wait. I try to never say never but for a $10 sandwich Nawwww I Dare Say I Won't Be Back. This was just a chicken sandwich on a Hoagie Bun. You Live n Learn

Goodfella`s Pizza
JM
Julie M Moon
google
03.27.2018
5/5

The CI is an amazing tasting pizza. The staff was friendly and helpful.

Goodfella`s Pizza
NG
Nathan Grossman
google
03.01.2018
3/5

Ordered a sandwich which tasted good until I found a large black hair in it. Probably won't be back which is unfortunate because I live nearby.Edit: I returned a few months ago and had their pizza, which was really good and no problems.

Goodfella`s Pizza
AG
Anita Gloyeski
google
02.15.2018
2/5

Pizza looked lousy and tasted about the same. Could have bought a $5 frozen pizza and it would have been better. North Manchester doesn’t have many options. This sadly isn’t a good one.

Goodfella`s Pizza
JM
Jade Marie
google
02.09.2018
1/5

Was told I had to wait an hour and 45 minutes. I ordered half cheese and half toppings on the other half. It came with toppings all over the whole pizza. I called back to tell them, the lady was very rude and told me to call back when I didn't have an attitude, when she was the one with the attitude, and also made me give the pizza back. Will not be ordering here again. Terrible experience.

Goodfella`s Pizza
KM
Karen Moore
google
02.01.2018
5/5

Always just what we wanted. Friendly, timely, and good eating

Goodfella`s Pizza
PY
Patrick Yoder
google
01.20.2018
5/5

Bosco sticks were great, pizza was great, shrimp scampi alfredo ravioli was amazing!

Goodfella`s Pizza
BM
Ben Makin
google
01.19.2018
4/5

Always enjoy going to Goodfellas. I love their calzone and you can fill it with whatever you want for no extra cost!! People always seem friendly there

Goodfella`s Pizza
AK
Art Kissel
google
11.13.2017
5/5

Great service and Food .

Goodfella`s Pizza
nugget
google
11.02.2017
5/5

Best pizza I have had in a long time. Big nice selection to choose from. And the theme inside works great. 5/5

Goodfella`s Pizza
SM
Saul Mota
google
10.26.2017
5/5

Great food . Great service

Goodfella`s Pizza
EJ
Erik Jarvis
google
10.25.2017
1/5

I got an order of wings from the north manchester location just now and the basket literally looks like it was already picked over/half-eaten!!! No exaggeration what-so-ever when I say that one of their employees walked past it and tried to take it thinking that it was a finished plate. After taking the plate to the manager I was given a fresh order (thankfully comped) that were sub-par at best. Also, my wife got a medium Spinach crust specialty pizza that was okay around the outside and WAY undercooked in the center. Our meal total was $38 for the two of us... Avoid this place at least until it gains some experience and balance.

Goodfella`s Pizza
TM
Troy Meyer
google
09.26.2017
5/5

Excellent food and service.Firs t time there.defintaly will come back.

Goodfella`s Pizza
JB
Jeff Brady
google
09.18.2017
5/5

Finally! A place with a delicious and crispy gluten free crust that doesn't turn into a burnt cracker with toppings or a soggy mess after cooking. An original crust recipe that is delicious. Ask for "The Club" - best chicken bacon pizza I've ever had.

Goodfella`s Pizza
JK
Jim Kane
google
08.15.2017
3/5

A good pizza place. Self serve drinks. Pizza was good and the bread sticks were good as well.

Goodfella`s Pizza
DB
Dj Brown
google
06.14.2017
4/5

Went to the north Manchester location. Food was delicious and reasonably priced. Service is good and staff really friendly. I will be back

Goodfella`s Pizza
Jl
James legg
google
06.08.2017
5/5

Good place to eat I highly recommend it to anybody

Goodfella`s Pizza
RB
Robin Baker
google
06.06.2017
4/5

Good pizza and subs

Goodfella`s Pizza
BH
Brenda Hetzner
google
05.19.2017
2/5

Not Great! We ordered a 18in pizza ...hardy.no pizza sauce. Very dry Very little toppings... I ordered bread sticks that tasted like dough nothing else. This place was great when it first opened....

Goodfella`s Pizza
RC
Rich Conrad
google
05.16.2017
3/5

Staff was very Friendly. Place looked clean. Restrooms were not dirty. Food was Ok. Crust was flaky but felt like it was frozen pizza. The food looks good but it’s deceiving.

Goodfella`s Pizza
AE
Andy Eadsville
google
05.09.2017
5/5

Nice personal touch. Always willing to go above and beyond for customers. They give back constantly to community. Of course the pizza and other food are phenomenal.

Goodfella`s Pizza
DU
Dennis Unger
google
04.18.2017
5/5

Great pizza and pasta

Goodfella`s Pizza
MB
Michelle Beeks
google
03.06.2017
5/5

Great food clean restaurant!!

Goodfella`s Pizza
PF
Pat French
google
02.23.2017
5/5

Went to the North Manchester location and it was seriously the best pizza I have ever had! The service was also very fast, and it was all crazy cheap. $11 for this giant two topping pizza! Definitely going back hopefully very soon. Glad North Manchester finally has something great that isn't overpriced. The gangster movie posters are a nice touch too :)

Goodfella`s Pizza
LG
Larry Gilley
google
02.22.2017
5/5

Good food at a great price. A community minded place.

Goodfella`s Pizza
KB
Kimberly Begley
google
11.22.2016
5/5

It was very good. Great food great service.

Goodfella`s Pizza
AF
Amy Frazier
google
11.17.2016
5/5

It was excellent service

Goodfella`s Pizza
CS
Christian Skordos
google
10.09.2016
4/5

While the service can be slow or inconsistent, the food is terrific. The breadsticks are delicious with any of the dipping sauces, but especially the garlic butter. The pasta is excellent though the Alfredo sauce can be overly thick with cheese. And the sandwiches are really good (try the chicken parm with pizza bread). Definitely worth a visit whenever you want some great local pizza.

Goodfella`s Pizza
KL
Kevin Lockwood
google
10.08.2016
4/5

Great pizza! Fresh ingredients and you have the choice of regular crust, a spinach crust, or a cauliflower crust; tried one spinach and one cauliflower and couldn't compare. Both are delicious but different. Thick layers of toppings and good flavor on sauce. Service was friendly.

Goodfella`s Pizza
CL
Christopher Logan
google
10.07.2016
5/5

Never been disappointed with anything on the menu! Great wings, pizza, and don't pass up on the pasta!

Goodfella`s Pizza
CR
Chris Rowe
google
09.01.2016
3/5

Pizza taste great, but they are kind of pricey

Goodfella`s Pizza
SD
Stace Drabenstot
google
07.10.2016
5/5

Excellent food and service!!!

Goodfella`s Pizza
SH
Steve Harrison
google
06.19.2016
5/5

Most excellent pizza!!!

Goodfella`s Pizza
SM
Suzy Miller
google
06.10.2016
5/5

My words escape me to tell you how GREAT their food is!! Wow!! Amazing!!

Goodfella`s Pizza
2H
2 Hippies Vintage
google
04.13.2016
4/5

Best non-Pizza Hut pizza in this town.Good service.

Goodfella`s Pizza
DY
Daniel Yohe
google
04.03.2016
4/5

A Wabash staple in the pizza business.

Goodfella`s Pizza
WB
Wes Brubaker
google
01.13.2016
5/5

Great food and service

Goodfella`s Pizza
MS
Michael Simpson
google
01.03.2016
1/5

Was told it would take 45 mins to an hour for our food to be delivered. It took close to hour and 45 mins. Ok and now the pizza was over cooked and dried out, taste like cardboard. Never had bad service like this from goodfellas before. Wont be ordering from here again!!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 12605691162

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!